The American Scream Jason: This documentary isn't for everyone. In fact, if you don't love Halloween – and I mean LOVE Halloween – you're not going to get it. And if you can't comprehend the mad desire to decorate your yard with anything but Christmas decorations , you shouldn't even be listening to this show. Suffice to say, I really dug Michael Stephenson 's documentary. For one, I got a lot of great ideas for what I want to do to my house and yard next year. For another, I found the people involved compelling. Even the weird, and clearly mentally ill , father/son duo were interesting in their own way. And I really, really want to visit Fairhaven one Halloween. It's become my Mecca . Obviously, this rates a Good in my book. Shawn: I found this to be quite a sad documentary. While Jay found inspiration, I saw sacrifice, obsession and divorce...haha. ...That said, documentaries aren't my forte. That is a drawback going in. This one was ...